Skip to content
Gone rogue · 2 sources ·
Picture from the lawgazette.co.uk article
Image: lawgazette.co.uk

Tax Appeal Cited Nine Cases ChatGPT Invented, Which Nobody Could Find Except the Judge

Ourtake

Nine invented precedents, zero hits on the official tribunal website. Even the AI's own citations needed a quick search.

What happened

A litigant in person challenging an HMRC penalty cited nine FTT decisions that a tribunal judge found were not genuine and had been generated by an AI system such as ChatGPT. The litigant said a contact in a solicitor's office had supplied them, and the tribunal rejected the appeal. The judge said fictitious citations waste tribunal and HMRC time and public money.

Sources

Report a mistake