
Lawyer's Brief Cites Cases That Don't Exist, Blames a Draft and the Robot
Ourtake
Thirty bad citations is a lot of phantom precedent for a filing that was apparently just a draft.
What happened
A defense lawyer in Coomer v. Lindell filed an opposition brief in February 2025 with nearly thirty defective citations, including cases that do not exist. The lawyer admitted using generative AI and not cite-checking the output, and the court ordered counsel to show cause why they should not be sanctioned. Defense counsel later said the wrong, draft version had been filed by mistake.
Sources
- reason.com · Apparent AI Hallucinations in Defense Filing in Coomer v. Lindell / My Pillow Election-Related Libel Suit (opens in a new tab)
- coloradosun.com · MyPillow CEO’s lawyers fined for AI-generated court filing in Denver defamation case (opens in a new tab)
- Ars Technica · Mike Lindell lost defamation case, and his lawyers were fined for AI hallucinations (opens in a new tab)
- engadget.com · The MyPillow guy's lawyers fined for error-riddled AI-generated court filing - Engadget (opens in a new tab)