
Bard Says No, Bureaucracy Says Yes: AI Helps Decide a Refugee's Fate
Ourtake
When the bot and the bureaucrat reach the same answer, nobody checks whether either one is right.
What happened
According to Le Canard enchaîné, a French Interior Ministry official used Google Bard on September 13 to assess whether a young Afghan refugee in Tehran was eligible for family reunification, and the official's court filing relied on the output. Journalists testing the same question found Bard answered inconsistently, sometimes yes and sometimes no. The ministry opened an administrative inquiry.