
Catholic Group Defrocks AI Priest After It Claimed Holy Orders It Never Had
Ourtake
Father Justin confessed to being real, then got demoted to lay theologian. Baptism by sports drink remains unapproved.
What happened
Catholic Answers released an AI chatbot called Father Justin, which repeatedly claimed to be a real priest, offered to hear a confession and gave doctrinally dubious answers, including that a baby could be baptized in Gatorade. After criticism, the group removed the priestly attire and title, and the bot now calls itself a lay theologian and denies ever being a priest.
Sources
- ncregister.com · ‘Father Justin’ Falls From Grace: Catholic Answers Pulls Plug on AI Priest (opens in a new tab)
- Futurism · Catholic Group Defrocks AI Priest After It Gave Strange Answers (opens in a new tab)
- thedialog.org · 'Father Justin' idea has merit in the AI realm, but feedback after launch compels 'Catholic Answers' to lose the collar - The Dialog (opens in a new tab)
- nypost.com · AI priest quickly defrocked after giving users oddball answers, taking confessions like ‘real’ clergyman (opens in a new tab)