
Judge's AI-drafted conviction arrives before the trial does, invents hearing dates along the way
Ourtake
The verdict was ready before the testimony ended. Somewhere a chatbot is still billing for the closing arguments.
What happened
Colombia's Supreme Court overturned a tutela ruling after a judge uploaded a draft criminal conviction, produced with an AI tool, before closing arguments in a trial. The AI-generated draft assessed evidence, proposed an 18-year sentence and falsely recorded hearings that had not yet occurred. The court ruled the defendant's rights had been violated and warned all judicial officials about responsible AI use.