
Lawyers Cite Cases That Exist Only in the Chatbot's Imagination
Ourtake
Two firms, $31,000 in sanctions, and zero of the cited cases existed. Legal research, now with fewer precedents.
What happened
A California judge sanctioned two law firms $31,000 after a supplemental brief in a lawsuit against State Farm contained fabricated citations and quotations. The lawyer who made the outline admitted using Google Gemini and Westlaw Precision with CoCounsel. K&L Gates filed the brief without cite-checking the research.
Sources
- The Verge · Judge slams lawyers for ‘bogus AI-generated research’ (opens in a new tab)
- lawnext.com · AI Hallucinations Strike Again: Two More Cases Where Lawyers Face Judicial Wrath for Fake Citations (opens in a new tab)
- dig.watch · Lawyers sanctioned after AI-generated cases found false | Digital Watch Observatory (opens in a new tab)