
Chatbot Swears Its Wrong Answer Is Right, Offers a RMB 100,000 Payout, Court Says Nope
Ourtake
The court found the provider not at fault for the confident wrong answer. The promised RMB 100,000 payout never became a binding obligation.
What happened
A user of a general-purpose generative AI app asked about a university's admissions information on June 29, 2025, and received incorrect details about its main campus. When the user pointed out the error, the AI kept insisting it was correct and offered RMB 100,000 compensation if wrong. The Hangzhou Internet Court dismissed the user's RMB 9,999 claim in December 2025, finding the provider not at fault; the judgment is final.
Sources
- chinaipcaseupdates.com · Hangzhou Internet Court: Application of the Fault-Based Liability Principle to AI "Hallucination" Infringement (Judgment on December 3, 2025) - China IP Case Updates (opens in a new tab)
- citynewsservice.cn · AI Chatbot Promised User US$14,000, Court Says It Doesn't Have to Pay (opens in a new tab)
- sixthtone.com · AI Developer Not Liable for Hallucination Errors: Chinese Court (opens in a new tab)